FEATURED HIGHLIGHTS

Public Advocates
in the Press

Feds Push MTC to Check Transit Projects for Civil Rights Compliance

FTA Opens New Investigation of MTC Press

New Stimulus Bill Approved, but Problems Over MOE May Loom
for California

Housing Bust Opens
New Doors for
Subsidized Tenants

MTC Adopts Aggressive
15% Target for Reducing Emissions by 2035

Pleasanton Settlement
Press

School Funding
Lawsuit Press

Data Nerd Alert:
New Comparability
Stats Coming

School Funding Potential Litigation Press

Stimulus Aid Yanks States' Spending Leash


Pleasanton Lawsuit Press

Feds Delay Education Stimulus Amid Concerns Over State's Accounting

Controversial School List Linked to State's Quest for Federal Funds

Transportation Nation: Speeding up the Pace of Spending (audio)

Concord Approves Naval Weapons Station Plan

Homeless, in Marin

School Groups Ask Duncan to Scrutinize Cuts in California

BART Stimulus Funds Oakland Airport Connector Press

Concord Takes Weapons Station Testimony as Plan Heads for Approval

Advice for the Concord City Council: Don't Leap Without Parachute

Housing Slump or Not, Concord Must Plan for New Development of
3000 Homes

Labor, Environmental, Neighborhood Groups Raise Questions on Weapons Staion Plan

Court to Rule Early
Next Year on Validity of
Pleasanton Housing Cap


Alameda County Judge Delays Decision
on Pleasanton's
Housing Cap

Transit Stimulation

City Can Be Sued
for Ignoring
Housing Numbers

Oakland Airport Connector: KALW Radio

Federal Civil Rights Review Could Imperil BART Airport
Connector Project

Feds to Check if BART Service and Fares Amounts to Bias

Fight against Oakland Airport Connector Leads to FTA Civil Rights Investigation of BART

Council Finalizes Rezoning of 32 acres
in Hacienda for
More Housing

Pleasanton Moves to Head Off Litigation

60,000 Teacher Jobs
Restored with Stimulus,
Educators Say
It's Not Enough

Rezoning Approval Irks Hacienda Residents

Veto of Schools
Bill 'Appalling'

OCR Complaint Filed Against California District Regarding ELLs

Letter to the Editor:
BART Boondoggle

Huffington Post Blog:
Time for Schwarzenegger
the Action Figure to
Emerge on Education

World Cup Goal:
Educate Every Kid

Op-Ed: School Matters: Obama’s Chance to
Spark Real School
Funding Reform

California Court of Appeal: "Spillover" Transportation Funds Can't Be Diverted!

Billions Could Go
Back to Transit:
California Supreme
Court Upholds Ruling

Tim Hunt: Pleasanton's Housing Cap Finally Gets Its Day in Court

Gascon Inherits Lawsuit Against Fong

Black Renters
Suing Antioch:
Study Backs Case

Superior Court Judge
Rejects Bid by
Pleasanton to Dismiss
Housing Cap Lawsuit

Judge Refuses to Dismiss Lawsuit Challenging Pleasanton Housing Cap

Teacher Certification a State Matter, Courts Rule

Discrimination Suit
Against Antioch
Dragging Through the
Legal Process

Novice Teachers Can
Still Count as "Highly
Qualified" in California


Appeals Court Rejects Trainee-Teacher Lawsuit

Local Advocates Mourn “Death of Transit” as Part of National Campaign

State Cannot Divert Gas Tax Revenue from Transit,
Court Rules

PA Partners
in the Press

Low-income Housing Project Opens up
in Pittsburg

East Bay Housing Groups Plan Cost, Climate Moves

Antioch Rebuts Allegations it Altered Tape of Police Officers' Conversation

Antioch Accused of Altering Evidence in Section 8 suit

Antioch Opposes
Class-Action Status
for ACLU Suit

The People Have Spoken

Drop the Housing Cap Now

Linda Darling-Hammond Honored With the 22nd Annual McGraw Prize in Education

Quality Education Litigations Bring "Extraordinary Leaps" in Equity and Opportunity:
New Jersey & California

High Court Says State Can't Raid Transit Funds

Other Related News

Antioch's Attorneys Accused of Cutting Disparaging Remarks from Audiotape in Bias Case

Transit Advocates
Will Push Lawmakers
to Rethink Transit
Funding Cuts

PolicyLink:
Real Progress
30 Years in the Making

2008 California Report Card: The State of the State's Children

Thank you for helping make Public Advocates
39th anniversary dinner a success!

.Details + REMAINING silent auction items!

FROM THE PRESIDENT                                                                                       July 2010

Public Advocates’ strategic planning and fiscal year starts July 1, and it’s already off to a powerful start.  On July 12, in Campaign for Quality Education v. State of California, we sued the State for failing in its constitutional duty to provide every student with an education that prepares them for college and career.

The year just ended was one for the record books. We’ve shared our milestones with you along the way:

  • a victory with statewide implications for affordable housing in Urban Habitat v. City of Pleasanton;
  • holding BART accountable for civil rights in the Oakland Airport Connector planning, generating national civil rights attention, and expanding transit operating support legislation;
  • blowing the whistle when the state tried to circumvent minimum education spending requirements in its application for federal stimulus funds;
  • shaping the discourse on the relationship of housing, transit, and climate justice and giving grass roots communities a voice in state policy making
  • making sure cities are meeting their obligations to provide their fair share of affordable housing situated near transit
  • Protecting the privacy of children who get free school lunches

We’re grateful for your faith in us, and the tangible support that lets us take risks and be courageous.  Thanks to you, we exceeded our fundraising goals and set records for both annual giving and annual event. We also broke through the $1M mark in grants from progressive, strategic foundations for policy, legal, coalition, and communication work.

So it’s a very happy “new year” for Public Advocates, as we resolve to remain fearless in the pursuit of justice,

Jamienne S. Studley signature
Jamienne S. Studley, President

PUBLIC ADVOCATES TAKES ACTION                                          

MTC Failures Spark Federal Review of Fairness Practices
New Civil Rights Investigation Probes Agency Role in Airport Connector Project

August 17, 2010— The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) has rejected claims by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) that it is not responsible for civil rights compliance by Bay Area transit operators, and opened a new investigation into MTC’s civil rights practices. The probe comes just six months after FTA withdrew $70 million in federal stimulus funds from BART after finding it had not complied with a range of civil rights protections.

press release    more about this case

State Report Reveals Large Numbers of Students in State's Worst Schools Still Being Taught By Unprepared Teachers
Legal settlement prompts progress in identifying & correcting problem

August 5, 2010 — A new California Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CTC) report finds that large numbers of students in the State’s lowest-performing schools, especially English language learners (ELs), are still being taught by teachers who lack the appropriate training or credential.

press release    more about this case

Advocates to Hold BART Accountable for Airport Tram Vote
Speak Out and Press Conference to Precede Thursday Board Meeting

July 21, 2010 —With key civil rights and technology still unresolved, and greater financial risk to BART than had ever been discussed, BART’s Board of Directors will consider giving final approval to the Oakland Airport Connector project at its Thursday, July 22 meeting. Members of the community, civil rights and environmental groups will hold a Speak Out and Press Conference prior to the meeting to urge BART Directors not to green-light the project until all the facts are in.

media advisory    more about this case

Grassroots Coalition Sues California Over School Funding
Says State Violating Fundamental Right to Education by Shortchanging Students

July 12, 2010 —A coalition of grassroots groups and individuals representing thousands of low-income students and parents from across California is suing the State of California over a school funding system that the Governor’s own Committee on Education Excellence said is “not equitable;…not efficient; and…not sufficient for students who face the greatest challenges.”

press release     amended complaint     complaint     plaintiff statements     attorney statements
press teleconference audio     PICO press release

Grassroots Groups Announce Plans to Sue California Over Inadequate,
Inequitable School Funding
Offer State Last Chance to Fix System

May 20, 2010 —The State of California faces an onslaught of further litigation if it does not immediately agree to fix its school finance system, promised the Campaign for Quality Education (CQE) in a demand letter being delivered to Governor Schwarzenegger today. The coalition of grassroots groups, representing thousands of low-income students and parents from across California, is offering the State one final chance to agree to transform a system that the Governor’s own Committee on Education Excellence said is "not equitable;…not efficient; and…not sufficient for students who face the greatest challenges.”

press release     demand letter    more about our education work

Transit Advocates to BART: Participation Plan a Good Start, Not Enough

May 12, 2010 —The coalition of transit advocates that brought the landmark civil rights complaint to the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) against the BART Oakland Airport Connector will present their response to BART's draft Public Participation Plan (PPP) at tomorrow's BART Board meeting. The plan is one of the requirements FTA placed on BART to rectify the numerous deficiencies uncovered by FTA's civil rights investigation of the agency last December.

media advisory     Response to BART's draft PPP    more about this case

Community Groups Respond to California Defense of Education Spending
Say State letter unresponsive, jeopardizing federal stimulus funding

March 19, 2010 —The Schwarzenegger Administration continues to put its application for vital federal education funds at risk by failing to recognize and comply with its “Maintenance of Effort” requirements, according to Parents and Students for Great Schools and the Campaign for Quality Education's Coordinating Committee.

press release     Response Letter from State to DOE     Community Group Response Letter to USDOE

Feds Hold up California's Application for Education Stimulus Funds
Action Prompted by Allegations by Community Groups and Education Community that State Circumventing Minimum Education Spending Requirements

March 9, 2010 —The U.S. Department of Education has informed Governor Schwarzenegger’s office that no decision will be made on California’s application to qualify for a second round of federal stimulus dollars for education until it responds to charges that the State is manipulating numbers in its attempts to avoid having to spend more on public education. Qualifying for the Recovery Act’s State Fiscal Stabilization Fund (SFSF) is also a precondition for California to receive Race To The Top (RTTT) funding.

press release     DOE letter

Reaction to California Failing to Make Finalist List for Federal Education Funding

March 4, 2010 —Unfortunately, we’re not surprised that California failed to make the list of Race To The Top (RTTT) finalists. Our state has been racing to the bottom of support for public education over the last two years, ignoring the fact that the neediest students continue to learn from the least-prepared, least-experienced and least-effective teachers.

full statement

Governor's Budget Imperils Federal Stimulus & RTTT Funds
Community Groups and Education Community Urge Duncan to Require California to Meet Minimum Education Spending Requirements

February 8, 2010 — The State of California is manipulating numbers in its attempts to qualify for federal stimulus and Race To The Top (RTTT) funding to avoid having to spend more on public education, according to a letter sent to Education Secretary Arne Duncan today by a coalition of community groups.

press release     letter    more about our education work

Court Strikes Down Pleasanton Housing Cap, Orders Rezoning For
Housing Near Jobs, Transit

March 15, 2010 —In a major affordable housing victory, Alameda Superior Court Judge Frank Roesch has ruled that the City of Pleasanton’s Housing Cap violates state law. In the first ruling of its kind, the court also ordered the city to complete re-zoning that is required by state law so that it can meet its share of the region’s affordable housing.

press release   decision   more about this case   Pleasanton Lawsuit Press   more on our Housing Element work

On Eve of Stimulus Anniversary,
Obama Administration Denies Funds Due to Civil Rights Failures
$70M taken from BART project, Distributed among Bay Area Transit Agencies

Funds Shift to Bay Area Transit Operations

February 16, 2010 —In the first action of its kind, the Obama Administration has pulled $70 million in federal stimulus funds from a proposed Oakland Airport Connector (OAC) project due to multiple civil rights violations by the Bay Area Rapid Transit district (BART). The strong action underscores a recent promise made in the President’s State of the Union address to continue “prosecuting civil rights violations.”

In a stern letter to BART and the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC), sent late Friday, Federal Transit Administration (FTA) Chief Peter Rogoff rejected BART’s “corrective action plan” seeking to address violations of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and advised MTC to reallocate the funds before a March 5 deadline.

press release     letter    more about this case

In Landmark Action, Federal Transit Administration Withholds Stimulus Funds from Bay Area Rapid Transit District for Cutting Corners on Civil Rights
Advocates Hail Decision Requiring BART to Evaluate Impacts of Controversial Transit Project on Low-Income and Minority Communities

January 25, 2010 — Today at 1:00pm EST, civil rights advocates, transportation equity experts and local leaders held a telephonic press conference to discuss the decision by the Federal Transit Administration (FTA), to withhold $70 million in stimulus funds from the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) agency. The FTA action was based on BART’s disregard of federal civil rights obligations. This marks the first time the Obama Administration has held back stimulus funds based on non-compliance with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination by recipients of federal funds.

National Transit Justice Press Conference (audio)     speakers and resources     speaker quotes
press release    more about this case

Obama Administration Puts Hold on BART Stimulus Funds
Say MTC and BART Put $70M at Risk Because of Failure to Follow Rules on Civil Rights

January 20, 2010 — In a major victory for Bay Area transit riders and workers the Federal Transportation Administration (FTA) has informed BART and the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) that the agencies have put at risk $70 million in stimulus funding currently allocated to the controversial Oakland Airport Connector (OAC) project. The action, the first of its kind in the nation, comes as a result of a complaint filed last Fall by nonprofit law firm Public Advocates Inc. on behalf of Urban Habitat, TransForm and Genesis, charging BART with failing to comply with federal civil rights obligations

press release     FTA Letter to MTC     MTC Certification     Plan for reallocation     Timeline
BART'S response to FTA letter    Our Statement on BART Response to FTA    Our Letter to MTC Commissioners
Our letter to BART 1.22.10     Our letter to BART 1.25.10   Our Letter to FTA 2.9.10    Our Letter to FTA 2.11.10
Press         

November 12, 2009 — The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) Office of Civil Rights will conduct an on-site compliance review of BART’s entire Title VI program “within the next several months,” based in part on a complaint filed by transit policy experts and community advocacy groups. That complaint charged that in the rush to build the controversial Oakland Airport Connector (OAC), BART officials were evading well-established civil rights obligations.   
press release    FTA letter   

As covered on KALW Radio, in Contra Costa Times, Oakland North and Living in the O.

October 12, 2009 — The Federal Transit Administration has assigned an investigator to our civil rights complaint about BART’s Oakland Airport Connector project. The investigation will be completed within 180 days, starting October 1.    FTA letter

September 3, 2009 — Entering a new phase in BART's controversial Oakland Airport Connector (OAC) project, Bay Area transit policy experts and community advocacy groups have filed a Title VI Civil Rights administrative complaint with the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) charging BART with failing to comply with federal civil rights obligations.

press release   complaint    more about this case

USDA and School Districts “Flunking Lunch" Says New Report
Misused Subsidies, Lunch Line Segregation Undermine School Lunch Program

December 15, 2009 — The fundamental goals of the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) to ensure healthy meals are offered to all students regardless of means are being undermined in schools across the nation, according to a new report by Campaign for Better Nutrition. Public Advocates provided legal analysis for the report.

“Segregating lunch lines for subsidized meals can be as damning as making these kids walk around with a scarlet “P” for poor,” said John Affeldt, Public Advocates Managing Attorney. “Congress intended the opposite—to preserve the anonymity of low-income children who participate in the school lunch program and to safeguard them from the stigma of poverty.”

press release     full report     more about our education work

Statement in Support of ACORN

November 23, 2009 — Public Advocates believes that real change and real justice only happen when disadvantaged and excluded communities organize, speak out together, and build their own power. That’s why we are proud to have worked for years with California ACORN as partners, friends, and lawyers.

read the statement

OP ED: School Matters: Obama’s Chance to Spark Real School Funding Reform

October 7, 2009 — Op-Ed by Public Advocates Staff Attorney Tara Kini: President Barack Obama and Secretary of Education Arne Duncan have an unprecedented opportunity to lead real school funding reform through the federal stimulus package. They can encourage states like California to fund public schools
adequately and equitably. The question is, will they?

op ed    our comments on the Race to the Top proposal    more about our education work

Federal Complaint Charges School District with Discrimination
Says Service Cuts Harm English Language Learner Students

October 6, 2009 — The Centinela Valley Union High School District in Lawndale, California has unlawfully discriminated against its English Language Learner (ELL) students, according to a complaint filed today with the U.S. Department of Education by nonprofit law firm and advocacy group Public Advocates Inc.

press release    complaint    more about our education equity work

PUBLIC ADVOCATES NEWS

Schott released report Yes We Can: Schott 50 State Report on Public Education and
Black Males

Dear Grantees, Allies and Colleagues:

Today, Schott released the attached report titled, Yes We Can: Schott 50 State Report on Public Education and Black Males. This latest biennial report reveals that the overall 2007/2008 graduation rate for Black males in the U.S. was only 47 percent. The report shows that out of 50 states, half have graduation rates for Black male students below the national average. New York’s graduation rate of only 25 percent for Black male students is the lowest of any state.  New York City, the district with the nation’s highest enrollment of Black students only graduates 28 percent of its Black male students on time.


view letter

John Affeldt & Guillermo Mayer to Serve as Panelists at Center for American Progress event Lifting the Fog of Averages: California’s Unique Law Around School Expenditure Reporting

May 26, 2010, 9:00am the Center for American Progress is hosting an event for the release of two new papers: "Lifting the Fog of Averages", which describes the motivation, passage, and enforcement of the the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009; and "Comparable, Schmomparable", which explores the data made available by it. The Act required that states furnish the Department of Education with a school-by-school report of actual expenditures by March 31, 2010. The data that emerge from this novel federal requirement promise to expose pervasive and substantial inequity, as foreshadowed by new research using data from California, which seized a leadership role in promoting transparency around school-level expenditure reporting with the passage of Senate Bill 687 in 2005. Affeldt and Mayer are featured panalists at the presentation.

view presentation video 

John Affeldt Participated in United Nations Human Rights Council Review Panel

The United Nations Human Rights Council is examining the United States’ compliance with its obligations under its Human Rights treaties, the UN Charter, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. As part of the process, the U.S. government is required to conduct consultations with stakeholders, including non-governmental organizations, civil society and those facing rights violations, to provide input regarding human rights in the United States. Mr. Affeldt was a panelist for the Berkeley consultation on Thursday, March 25, 2010, which focused on Health, Education, and State Accountability.

event details

Guillermo Mayer was Panelist at Transportation Equity Network’s Annual Conference

On March 15, 2010 Senior Staff Attorney Guillermo Mayer was a panelist at the Transportation Equity Network’s annual conference "A Seat at the Table." Joining him at the session, The Moment in FTA: Growing Awareness of Civil Rights, was Bob Allen from our close ally Urban Habitat.

Staff Promotions

Congratulations to Guillermo Mayer and Michelle Natividad Rodriguez, who have been promoted to the new position of Senior Staff Attorney. Also to Samuel Tepperman-Gelfant, who was recently named Staff Attorney. We congratulate them all.

Parisa Fatehi Participated in Clorox/Stanford Law School/Equal Justice Works Panel

On February 19, 2010, Clorox General Counsel Laura Stein, Stanford Law School Associate Dean Diane Chin, and Equal Justice Works Fellow Parisa Fatehi held an evening of conversation and more as Equal Justice Works brought together some of the Bay Area's leading attorneys and the next generation of public interest lawyers.

details

Studley was Participant in "Stimulating Equity? The Impact of the Federal Stimulus Act on Educational Opportunity"

February 8 - 9, 2010 Teachers College, Columbia University held the first major national forum to analyze,
in-depth, the impact of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act on educational equity and on educational opportunity. 

agenda

Studley Named to Prestigious National Committee

December 21, 2009 President and CEO Jamienne S. Studley was named by Secretary of Education Arne Duncan to the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI). The Committee advises the Secretary on matters related to accreditation, including decisions to recognize accrediting organizations.
 
release

Public Advocates' Sacramento Office Has Moved

The Public Advocates Sacramento office has moved to a new suite within the same building. Please send all mail to: 1225 Eighth Street, Suite 210, Sacramento, CA 95814. The phone and fax numbers remain the same: 916/442-3385(o), 916/442-3601(f).

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

Home | About Us | Our Work | News | Donate | Jobs | Resources | Contact Us |